Learn / Gearbox & Gearing / Up-shift & down-shift analysis: shift points, shift time, blips, over-rev
L2 · Practitioner

Up-shift & down-shift analysis: shift points, shift time, blips, over-rev

Optimal upshift rpm maximises the power used between post-shift and shift rpm; shift time is read from the longitudinal-g dip; down-shifts need a correct blip and must be protected against over-rev.

Up-shift & down-shift analysis: shift points, shift time, blips, over-rev: L1 Foundation explanation

Shift point. Shifting at the rev limiter is not automatically best. After an upshift the engine drops to nafter=nshift⋅in+1/inn_{after} = n_{shift} \cdot i_{n+1}/i_n. What matters is the power the engine delivers over the rpm range it actually works in — from naftern_{after} to nshiftn_{shift}. Segers' F3 example: with ≈ 1200 rpm drop per shift, the area under the power curve between post-shift and shift rpm was maximised at 6500 rpm, not at 7000. A simulated 1 km acceleration test was 0.12 s quicker with 6 km/h higher top speed when shifting 500 rpm earlier.

Exact rule (which Segers' area method approximates): upshift when the power at the current rpm equals the power at the post-shift rpm — at the same road speed, force = P/v, so beyond that point the next gear gives more force. The area method gives the same answer when the rpm drop is a fixed number of rpm, as in Segers' example. When the drop scales with the ratio (na=ns in+1/inn_a = n_s\,i_{n+1}/i_n), use the mean power over [na,ns][n_a, n_s], not the raw sum: with a proportional drop the raw sum biases the shift late, often all the way to the limiter.

Check it in data: look at longitudinal g across an upshift. After the dip, acceleration should resume on the same downward-sloping trend line as before. If it resumes lower (a step down), the shift rpm was too low; if acceleration was already sagging before the shift, it was too high.

Shift time. Time in a shift is time without drive. Read it from the longitudinal-g dip — from where drive drops off to where it recovers. Segers' reference values:

Car / system (Segers Table 6.3, early-2000s data)Upshift time
F3 car0.15 s
Porsche 911 GT2 Turbo, synchronised H-pattern0.35 s
Dodge Viper GTS-R, synchronised H-pattern0.32 s
Viper GTS-R, sequential, no power-shift0.23 s
Viper GTS-R, sequential + power-shift (ignition cut)0.18 s
LMP1 prototype, sequential, electronic paddle-shift0.10 s

Modern paddle-shift GT3 and formula cars typically cut drive for ≈ 40–80 ms. Dual-clutch boxes (PDK/DCT in GT4 and some one-make cars) hand torque over between two clutches, with almost no gap. You need ≥ 50 Hz (better 100 Hz) logging of long g to measure this.

Down-shifts. The engine must be sped up to match the lower gear — the driver (or auto-blip) blips the throttle. Too little blip: the rear wheels have to accelerate the engine — a braking torque spike on the rear axle mid-trail-braking → snap oversteer. Too much: over-rev. Most over-revs happen on downshifts — from shifting down too early (rpm too high) or over-blipping.

Key formulas

rpm after upshift
nafter=nshiftin+1inn_{after} = n_{shift} \frac{i_{n+1}}{i_n}
Equal-power shift criterion
P(nshift)=P ⁣(nshiftin+1in)P(n_{shift}) = P\!\left(n_{shift} \frac{i_{n+1}}{i_n}\right)
rpm after downshift (over-rev check)
nafter=nbeforein−1in≤nmaxn_{after} = n_{before} \frac{i_{n-1}}{i_n} \le n_{max}
Time cost of an upshift gap (first order)
Δtshift≈ts FF−D(1−vshiftvbrake)\Delta t_{shift} \approx t_s\, \frac{F}{F - D}\left(1 - \frac{v_{shift}}{v_{brake}}\right)

Trackside takeaways

  • Shift where power at current rpm equals power at post-shift rpm — often below the limiter.

  • After an upshift, long g should resume on the pre-shift trend; a step down means the shift was too early.

  • Measure shift time from the long-g dip; log long g at ≥ 50 Hz.

  • Insufficient blip = rear braking spike on entry; excessive blip/early downshift = over-rev.

  • Downshift lock-out events in the log mean the driver is downshifting too early.

  • Rising shift times over a stint are an early gearbox/actuator failure indicator.

On your car

Pneumatic or electric paddle shift with auto-blip and ignition cut; cut/blip calibrations largely homologated. Engineers set shift lights per gear and monitor shift times and refused downshifts.

Check yourself

Question 1 / 5L2 · Practitioner

After each upshift the longitudinal-g trace recovers to a value clearly below the extrapolated pre-shift trend. What does this tell you?

Further reading
  • Segers – Analysis Techniques for Racecar Data Acquisition — §6.1.1 Shifting Point · area under power curve, F3 example, long-g trend check
  • Segers – Analysis Techniques for Racecar Data Acquisition — §6.1.2 Shift Duration · shift time from long-g, typical durations, sampling rate
  • Segers – Analysis Techniques for Racecar Data Acquisition — §6.2 Down-shifting · blipping, over-rev causes