# Why a differential: the open diff and its inside-wheel limitation

> In a corner the outside wheel must turn faster than the inside one. An open diff allows that by splitting torque equally — which caps total drive at twice what the weakest (inside) wheel can transmit.

Area: Differential · Starting level: L1 Foundation · Updated 2026-11-17
Source page: https://race-engineer-academy.vercel.app/lesson/diff-why-open-diff

## L1 · Foundation

**Kinematics.** In a corner of radius $R$ (at the car's centreline) with track width $t$, the outside wheel follows a radius $R + t/2$ and the inside $R - t/2$. Their speed difference is

$$\Delta V = V \frac{t}{R} = t\, \dot\psi$$

where $\dot\psi$ is the yaw rate. Example: rear track 1.6 m, 50 m radius → 3.2 % speed difference; in a 15 m hairpin → 10.7 %. A solid axle (a **spool**) forces both wheels to the same speed, so one or both tyres must slip longitudinally to reconcile it — scrubbing tyres and creating a yaw moment that resists turning.

**The open differential** lets the wheels turn at different speeds. Its defining property: **torque is split equally** between left and right (ignoring internal friction), whatever their speeds:

$$T_L = T_R = \tfrac12 T_{in}$$

**See it on the bench.** Below, a plate-type limited-slip differential is cut open. The crown wheel drives the carrier, the lit spider gears let the two half-shafts turn at different speeds, and the clutch packs (LSD mode) add a locking torque. The bars show each wheel's torque and its speed relative to the carrier; the chart shows how input torque is split.

**Try it:**
- Choose **Open** and tighten the corner from 150 m to **12 m**: the speed bars split (inside wheel slower, outside faster, about **53 rpm** apart) but the torque bars stay equal – **1200 / 1200 Nm** at 2400 Nm input.
- Switch to **Plate LSD**: the slower inside wheel now gets more – **1715 / 685 Nm**. The difference is the locking torque, **120 Nm preload + 0.38 × input torque**.
- Lower the input torque: the split narrows, because the ramps clamp the plates harder only when more torque goes through.

**Takeaway:** an open diff always splits torque equally, so the wheel with less grip limits both. An LSD sends extra torque to the slower wheel – more traction on corner exit, at the cost of a yaw moment that resists the car turning.

**The limitation.** Each wheel can only transmit as much torque as its tyre can carry. In a corner, lateral load transfer unloads the inside rear — on a GT car at 1.5 g it can lose 50–70 % of its static load. Because the open diff always sends equal torque, the moment the inside wheel reaches its grip limit, **the outside wheel cannot get any more either**. Add more throttle and the inside wheel spins up (the open diff happily lets it), while the outside wheel — with plenty of load and grip — stays at the same torque.

Total drive force with an open diff is therefore

$$F_{x,total} = 2\, F_{x,inside,max}$$

That is the classic **inside-wheel spin** out of slow corners (or, on a lifted wheel, zero drive). It is why almost every racing car uses a **limited-slip differential (LSD)**: it lets the diff transfer extra torque to the slower, better-loaded wheel.

The cost of locking: the more the diff resists speed difference, the more it behaves like a spool — yaw resistance and understeer in some phases, sudden oversteer in others. Managing that trade-off is diff setup.

## L2 · Practitioner

**Seeing it in data.** With both driven-wheel speeds logged (Segers §4.2 recommends it precisely to evaluate the diff):
- Compute $\Delta V_{rear} = V_{out} - V_{in}$ (choose left/right per corner direction, or use the sign of $a_y$) and compare it with the kinematic expectation $t\,|\dot\psi|$ (or $t\,|a_y|/V$).
- Inside-wheel spin = the inside wheel becoming **faster** than kinematics allows — often faster than the outside wheel. In Segers' La Source example, separate slip channels for each rear wheel show which wheel is at the limit.
- With an open diff, inside spin appears together with low longitudinal acceleration and (if fitted) TC intervention, because TC sees average driven-wheel speed rising.

**Numbers for the limitation.** GT3, 1300 kg, rear static load ≈ 3.6 kN per wheel. Exiting a slow corner at 1.2 g lateral, lateral load transfer on the rear axle ≈ 1.5–2 kN: inside rear ≈ 1.8 kN, outside ≈ 5.4 kN. With μ ≈ 1.5 and the tyre also producing lateral force, the inside rear may support only ≈ 1–1.5 kN of drive force. Open diff total ≈ 2–3 kN; the outside wheel alone could carry ≈ 4–5 kN. Most of the available traction is wasted.

**FWD is worse.** In a TCR car, longitudinal load transfer *also* unloads the front, so inside-front spin starts very early. Open diffs in FWD racing are rare; mechanical LSDs dominate, at the price of torque steer.

**Why not just a spool?** A spool gives maximum traction in a straight line and on a lifted wheel, but in a steady corner it imposes $\Delta V = 0$: the outside tyre is forced to under-rotate (negative slip, braking force) and the inside to over-rotate (drive force). That creates a moment **opposing the turn** — classic spool understeer (RCVD Ch. 20). Karts live with it by lifting the inside rear; racing cars use LSDs to get between the two extremes.

**Brakes as a diff substitute.** Applying the inside brake transfers torque through an open diff to the outside wheel (brake-based TC / "e-diff" in road cars). In racing this is generally banned or impractical (brake heat), so the mechanical LSD carries the job.

## L3 · Advanced

**Torque balance with internal friction.** A real open diff has internal friction (gear mesh, thrust washers), giving a small **torque bias ratio (TBR)** ≈ 1.1–1.3. In general a diff with locking torque capacity $T_{lock}$ obeys, when the wheels rotate at different speeds:

$$T_{slow} - T_{fast} = T_{lock}, \quad T_{slow} + T_{fast} = T_{in}$$

— **torque goes to the slower wheel**. When the wheels turn at the same speed (diff not slipping), the split is set by the tyres, with $|T_L - T_R| \le T_{lock}$.

This "torque to the slower wheel" rule is the key to all diff yaw effects:
- In a corner on throttle with no wheelspin, the **outside wheel is faster** → an LSD sends extra torque to the **inside** wheel → a yaw moment that **resists rotation** (understeer).
- Once the inside wheel spins and becomes faster than the outside, extra torque goes to the **outside** wheel → a moment that **promotes rotation** (oversteer) and much higher total traction.

So an LSD does not have a fixed "understeer" or "oversteer" character; it switches sign depending on which wheel is faster. That transition — from **outside-wheel-faster (push)** to **inside-wheel-faster (snap)** — is exactly what drivers describe as "it pushed, then it snapped". In data it is the **sign change of the measured $V_{out} - V_{in}$** (the locking index $L$ of the data lesson crossing 1), not merely a deviation of $\Delta V_{rear}$ from $t\dot\psi$: any diff that restrains the speed difference at all pulls $\Delta V_{rear}$ below kinematics, long before the flip. Recognising the flip is the core skill of diff tuning.

**Tyre-side view.** At a given axle drive force $F_x$, the split $F_{x,o}/F_{x,i}$ affects each tyre's combined-slip state. The lightly loaded inside tyre saturates first; loading it with *more* drive (LSD in the non-spinning state) can bring it to its limit early, after which the diff state flips. Optimal locking keeps both rear tyres near their combined limit simultaneously — which is impossible with a passive diff over all corner phases, and is why active diffs (where permitted) are so effective.

## Key formulas

**Kinematic wheel-speed difference**

$$\Delta V = V\frac{t}{R} = t\,\dot\psi$$

- t: track width (m)
- R: corner radius (m)
- \dot\psi: yaw rate (rad/s)

**Open diff torque split**

$$T_L = T_R = \tfrac12 T_{in}$$


**Open diff traction limit**

$$F_{x,total} = 2\, F_{x,inside,max}$$


**Diff with locking capacity (slipping)**

$$T_{slow} - T_{fast} = T_{lock}$$


## Trackside takeaways

- Outside wheel must turn faster: ΔV = t·yaw rate (≈ 3 % in a 50 m corner, > 10 % in a hairpin).
- Open diff = equal torque: total drive = 2 × what the unloaded inside wheel can take.
- A spool kills inside spin but resists rotation in steady cornering.
- An LSD always sends extra torque to the SLOWER wheel — its yaw effect flips sign when the inside wheel starts to spin.
- Log both driven-wheel speeds to see what the diff is doing.

## By car category

### GT3

Mechanical LSD (plate/ramp) with preload and limited ramp options; open diffs are never used.

### TCR

FWD with mechanical front LSD: essential for traction but produces torque steer and power understeer; drivers fight the wheel on exits.

### Formula 4

Low power: inside spin is less dramatic, but slow hairpins still show it; the spec diff configuration limits what the engineer can do.

### Hypercar (LMH/LMDh)

LMH front axle (when driven above the threshold) also needs a diff; rear axle LSD behaviour interacts with the hybrid torque split.

## References

- Milliken & Milliken, Race Car Vehicle Dynamics (SAE 1995): Ch. 20 Driving and Braking (differential types, spool vs open, yaw moments from drive)
- Segers, Analysis Techniques for Racecar Data Acquisition, 2nd ed. (SAE 2014): §4.2 Traction and Longitudinal Slip (separate driven-wheel slip channels to evaluate differential work)
